The prize under the cap

The author heard this story from a marketer at Coca-Cola’s Russian office.

Many people remember the promotion that ran in the 1990s. Icons printed on the inside of Coca-Cola bottle caps stood for prizes: a free drink at McDonald’s, a soccer ball, a bicycle and so on. Among the prizes there was one Grand Prize. It was a large sum of money, say, a million dollars.

How do you run a promotion like that? At first glance, it is very simple: a dollar icon is honestly printed on one of the caps, at the factory the cap is screwed onto a random bottle, the bottle goes to a store, someone buys it, unscrews the cap, finds the Grand Prize under it, claims it and becomes a millionaire.

Preparations began. Ordinary caps were marked with prizes, screwed onto bottles and sent to stores exactly as described. Then it was the Grand Prize’s turn. The cap with the million-dollar icon was specially made in a single copy, and the president of Coca-Cola Russia himself, accompanied by a dozen people, walked into the factory along a red carpet, holding a crystal box with the precious cap. He approached the conveyor to toss it into the pile with the other caps. And froze, because the whole neat plan had collapsed in an instant.

First, it turned out that a certain share of bottles is always defective. There is a one-in-several-hundred-thousand chance that the capping machine will strip the thread or fail to pick up a cap, so the cap will never end up on a bottle. The defect rate is tiny, less than 0.001%. But there is still a chance that it will be the Grand Prize cap that never gets screwed on, never reaches a store and is never bought.

So the cap has to be screwed on and sealed by hand, or someone has to watch the machine. Not a big deal, since we are already at the factory.

The first problem was solved quickly. But a second one came up right away: when Coca-Cola leaves the factory, nobody controls which region a particular bottle goes to. There is simply no need: a crate is loaded onto a random truck and goes wherever it goes. The trouble was that the promotion ran only in certain stores that had signed an advertising contract, and only in Moscow, St. Petersburg and a few nearby cities. What to do?

This could be solved quite simply: take the bottle off the conveyor, ask the drivers where their loads are going, and put the crate with the prize bottle on the right truck.

Not so fast. Only some of the bottles delivered to a store end up on its shelves. The store sends the rest to partner outlets and sells them to corporate clients. How can you make sure the bottle doesn’t end up at some reception where a waiter pours it into glasses without even looking under the cap?

Well, there was no other way. They had to pick a random store in Moscow, go there in person and put the bottle on the shelf. And make sure the cashiers or security guards didn’t take it.

So there it is: the Grand Prize bottle, standing on the shelf among other bottles of Coca-Cola. People come into the store, buy things, look around. Although the bottle stands in the most visible spot, as luck would have it, customers keep taking other bottles. One hour passes, then two, and the bottle is still there. A homeless man walks in. He wanders through the aisles and approaches the soda shelf. He looks… and looks… and reaches for the bottle. At this point the team of managers hiding in ambush can’t take it anymore. They rush to the shelf and practically snatch the bottle out of his hands, because it is obvious to everyone: he will unscrew the cap, toss it in the trash without looking, and the whole promotion will go down the drain!

Here is how the story ended. The managers simply stood by the shelf and waited for the first respectable-looking customer. When he walked up and started choosing a soda, they handed him the prize bottle themselves: “Young man, take this one, it might be a winner!” Of course, it turned out that he hadn’t come for Coca-Cola but for Baikal, a Russian soda, so they had to talk him into it for a while. Then they had to get him to open the bottle right there in the store. Then get him to look under the cap. Then get him to give an interview and come to collect the Grand Prize, because for a long time he couldn’t believe any of it. But in the end the promotion took place, and the “winner” was found.

This is an embellished but entirely true story about how people tend to underestimate the complexity of ideas that look simple at first glance. In an era of fast-moving internet technology, judgment gets dulled. It starts to seem that any idea can be brought to life with a snap of the fingers. In fact, even the simplest idea hides a huge number of nuances and pitfalls under the hood and may turn out to be completely unrealistic.

In his work, the author often runs into oversimplified ideas. “It’s just a map with dots,” says a client describing a courier delivery service with geolocation. “It’s just a video site,” says another who wants to build his own YouTube. As a rule, they are all very surprised when the conversation turns to the couple of million rubles their project will cost.

Every time you catch yourself reducing an idea to “It’s just…”, it is worth stopping and remembering the Coca-Cola story: it was just a prize under the cap.