The history of the paragraph
Paragraph indentation is a well-known typographic technique taught in the very first lessons of elementary school.
Put your hand on the copybook and indent about two fingers’ width to mark the beginning of a new paragraph, a new thought. What could be simpler? In fact, this technique has a long and interesting history.
Long ago, even before Gutenberg invented printing, there was already a way to show where one of the author’s thoughts ended and another began. It had nothing to do with the way paragraphs are marked in books today. There was no indentation at the beginning of a line, and no line breaks at all. The text ran as a solid wall, and breaks were marked with a special symbol that probably everyone who has ever used Microsoft Word has seen.
¶
Line break, carriage return, paragraph mark, alinea — the odd-looking pilcrow (Unicode 0x00B6) goes by many names today, and hardly anyone suspects that it is not Microsoft Word’s invention but a sign with almost a thousand years of history. Its shape comes from the letter C, the first letter of the Latin word capitulum, meaning “chapter.” As far as the author knows, the sign took its final form in 1400–1450 and evolved roughly as follows:
The modern section sign § is a degenerate version of this original mark, which was placed inside a line and highlighted in color to signal the start of a new group of sentences. Before printing was invented, the sign was added to books by hand by a separate person, the rubricator. Book of Games of King Alfonso X, 13th century:
By the end of the Middle Ages, paragraphs started on a new line, but the habit of adding the sign did not disappear right away. It was traditionally placed at the beginning of the line. Opera Vergiliana & Anais Vergiliiana, 1517:
The paragraph sign was placed at the beginning of the line and was usually highlighted in red. This is the root of at least two terms: the Russian “red line,” meaning paragraph indentation, and “rubric.” The word “rubric” comes from the Latin rubrum, “red.” This is also where the name of the rubricator’s profession comes from: a person who marks the rubrics in a text.
So where did the sign go, and why don’t we see it in texts today? It is a wonderful example of the hole in a donut: the sign is gone, but its place remains. The rubricator did his work after the main text of the book had been written, and the scribe or typesetter deliberately left space for the sign. For some reason, though, the sign was often left out, and eventually all that remained was the indent at the beginning of the line.
By not filling in the sign, lazy medieval bookmakers gave the world the best and most obvious way to mark a paragraph: a small indent on the first line. Since then, this method has been used everywhere, and the “holes” at the beginning of paragraphs still seem to be waiting for the rubricator’s hand to fill them in at last.