Russian web design

Does Russian web design exist?

Of course, this is not about Russian studios staffed by Russian designers: nobody doubts that they exist. The question is whether there are distinctive features, a set of rules, techniques and approaches, typical of websites made specifically by Russian web designers.

The author is sure that such differences exist and that their roots go deep into history, which makes it possible to single out Russian web design as a distinct approach to building websites.

History of European design

The story begins in the 19th century, the era of emerging industrial capitalism, the rapid growth of wage labor and accelerating economic growth.

This is when the modern idea of design as applied artistic work is born. The growth of industrial production, trade and private business creates a natural need to advertise goods. To make advertisements, signboards and posters, the businessmen of the time turned to painters, letterers, engravers, folk print makers and printers.

That is why old posters had rich, lavish decoration. They mostly showed people, engraved or painted in watercolor, presenting the product, for example, holding it in their hands.

Posters were often framed with borders full of monograms and flourishes and filled with text. A single advertising poster used on average five to ten different kinds of lettering, counting different styles and treatments of the same typeface. As a rule, the typefaces came from different styles, and the lettering was bent, stretched and painted in different colors. The result was a motley typographic pattern. This genre is called eclecticism, a mixture of styles. Usually, the older the work, the more varied its lettering.

Because of their unique decoration, these early examples of design, posters and playbills, feel more like a special kind of art than design in the modern sense: they are so distinctive and rich.

But design is not art. Art expresses ideas and describes the world, while design solves problems, even if it uses painting or sculpture to do so. An advertising poster or playbill has a specific task first of all: to sell a product or service. The main driving force of design, its very essence, is solving real-world problems, usually commercial ones.

As the 20th century approached and beyond, business tasks became more and more specific, competition grew, and both demand and the number of goods increased. Problems had to be solved faster and in ever greater volume. The growing need for design gradually led to its natural separation from art. As goods turned over faster, it became impossible, or at least unnecessary, to paint a whole picture for every advertising poster and present every product in a unique way.

Posters of 1920–1950 no longer look as rich as those of the previous century. Instead, they become more specific: the product name and its main advantages stand out clearly, and there is accompanying copy. Some posters carry a great deal of text, which becomes a separate branch of marketing, but most often designers limit themselves to a few phrases that name and briefly describe the product.

But there is another reason for the simplification: the emergence of new movements in the visual arts. The avant-garde, surrealism and abstract art are born. Art no longer depicts people. Its goal now is harmony between geometric shapes and color that evokes the right associations in the viewer. It is as if art is now learning problem solving from design rather than the other way around. This new vision of the world reaches the advertising poster and, with it, graphic design.

From then on, a graphic language, the language of color, form and composition, begins to take shape. It reaches its peak in the 1960s–1990s. The advertising posters of that time are a true celebration of form, incredibly expressive and powerful works.

Finally, this period brings the main invention that graphic design had been working toward for so long: the grid, or the Swiss modular layout system. The world owes it to Jan Tschichold, Emil Ruder, Max Bill and other famous graphic designers of the mid-20th century.

Thanks to the modular grid, elements on posters, book spreads, newspapers and magazines are placed not by eye or by intuition but along a strictly drawn grid of vertical and horizontal lines that divides the page into blocks, or modules. In a sense, this transfers the ideas of architecture to print. Now posters, too, are built according to the golden ratio and the laws of geometry.

And so, armed with form, color and the grid, European design meets the end of the 20th century and the arrival of the internet. A qualitatively new chapter begins. Design goes digital. A new task appears: creating websites. Demand for websites starts to grow. Who supplies it? The same masters who worked on advertising, posters, playbills, magazines, newspapers and so on. Print designers.

But a computer screen is not a sheet of paper. Monitors can be large or small, wide or tall, with a 4:3 or 16:9 aspect ratio, and the browser window can be resized at will. Print never had to deal with that.

So what do these newly minted print-designers-turned-web-designers do? Not only do they have no idea what to do with a canvas of variable size, they can’t even imagine it: a size that changes? The ability of a web page to take any size is simply ignored, treated as something foreign. A website is made the way a poster would be: the layout gets a fixed width at which the design looks acceptable on most monitors, and blocks are placed on a grid. Everything else, form, color and composition, is carried over from print.

Unlike posters, web design usually uses the simplest grid, which divides a fixed-width canvas (960 pixels) into 12, 16 or 24 columns. Fitting every element of the page onto the grid is quite hard, so only the main blocks are placed on it, and exceptions are made for the rest. Vertical alignment is rarely used.

This is European web design. With a century-long history behind it, well thought out and clear. Not drawn. Designed.

History of Russian design

So, the main driving force of Western design was the growth of business, advertising and printing, which pushed designers to find simple, effective techniques and give up labor-intensive beauty.

What happened in Russia? It started exactly the same way as in the West. Russian commerce was thriving. Russian advertising was in no way inferior to European examples and sometimes surpassed them, as confirmed not only by flawless and charming pre-revolutionary works but also by the opinions of Europeans.

It must be said that Russia adopts many movements from the West, but then takes them to a whole new level, reaching an incredible depth of self-expression. For example, if European works of the late 19th century were eclectic, in Russia it was eclecticism squared, super-eclecticism. A single page could use dozens of typefaces.

The avant-garde was no exception and developed powerfully into Soviet constructivism. Alexander Rodchenko, Anton Lavinsky, El Lissitzky and other masters of the new era did incredible things with form, achieving stunning dynamism in their posters.

The Soviet poster of the 1920s becomes first and foremost a means of mass communication and propaganda. It uses loud, punchy, short slogans. The poster stops being art (at least in the usual sense) and becomes an object of applied graphics. A new profession appears: the artist-constructor, or advertising constructor, as Rodchenko signed his works. The concept of industrial artistic work is born. In other words, design itself appears.

Another distinctive feature of Soviet posters of that time is the frequent use of photography, then the latest technical achievement. Posters with photographs usually turned into motley collages of drawings, lettering and photos. Anyone who distinguishes between eclecticism and chaos would probably file these works under the latter.

A few quotes are enough to capture the essence of advertising and poster making of that time.

When a slogan has to be thrown to the masses, when their attention has to be drawn to some event, when a single idea has to be instilled, the poster reigns supreme. And the shorter, punchier and simpler the slogan, the better the poster and the easier it is to make it vivid, clear and striking.
V. P. Polonsky, Press and Revolution
The graphic artist began to understand that the purpose of a thing and its idea determine its form, and this understanding should be considered the starting point for the many branches of graphic art.
B. Zemenkov
An ideologically and artistically expressive arrangement of these elements (slogan, graphics, poster) can only be achieved by an entirely new type of artist: a public activist, a specialist in mass political and cultural work, a constructor who masters photography and builds his compositions on entirely new principles never before used in art.
G. Klutsis

However, Soviet power brought not only the avant-garde but also a long period without any private enterprise, and therefore without any need for commercial design. On top of that, whether as a consequence or not, came a period of stagnation in practically all printed matter: advertising posters, glossy magazines, newspapers and books.

Of course, the Soviet Union had advertising, magazines, newspapers and books; it would be foolish to claim otherwise. But there were only publications tied to major national “brands,” Party media, or whatever was permitted to be printed, and that was printed only by the big state publishers. Such a system left no room for competition or the free development of design techniques. Design could not develop in the wild, outside the studios of a handful of Soviet advertising geniuses.

The hidden problem of Soviet graphic design, which smoldered in the cauldron of censorship and eventually left Russian design stagnant and lagging behind, a problem that still haunts many designers and their clients, becomes clear when you look at a late Soviet poster.

And you discover that there is no conceptual difference between the posters of the 1970s, 1960s, 1930s and 1920s. Formally, they differ in typefaces, technique, richness of decoration and style. In fact, the late Soviet poster is still the same early Soviet poster, or the poster of late tsarist Russia, presented slightly differently.

While over the same period design in the West changed radically, moving from chaos to form and developing the modular grid and concise presentation, in the Soviet Union the poster stopped where capitalism stopped. The mystery that puzzles so many has a simple answer: there is no design where there is no business. Graphic design primarily solves the problem of advertising goods and services. And it pays to solve these problems where there is healthy competition and no censorship, where such tasks arise on a massive scale, where there is entrepreneurship. In other words, design exists where capitalism exists.

In the early 1990s, the USSR ended and the World Wide Web began. Russians gradually acquired computers and dial-up internet access. The internet started filling up with the first web pages. In the second half of the 1990s, the concept of web design was born.

But the people who come to Russian web design are not print designers at all: they simply did not exist as a class. Ordinary users, programmers, HTML coders, anyone at all become web designers. And what they bring to the web is not the modular grid, known only to a handful of enlightened people, but whatever understanding of design they picked up from Soviet times. In short, the first Russian web designers are anything but professionals.

This is a huge drawback. Yet there is one advantage that decides the fate of the Russian web: Russian web designers have no preconceptions about screen size. Russian web designers who had never worked in print and had never heard of grids, alignment, composition, typography or other achievements of the passing century do the impossible: they use all the free space on the screen! Russian websites come out fully stretchable, text blocks rarely follow a grid and stretch across the full width, images float around the screen. The result is a “rubber” layout. The natural behavior of the web, unthinkable in the West and only now being approached by European design, is born in Russia on its own, out of ignorance.

One of the best examples of Russian web design is the website of the Felix Zavoisky hotel by Art. Lebedev Studio. The site stretches across the whole screen and looks equally good everywhere, from very small monitors to giant ones. And there is no grid: the spacing between blocks is completely free, the text expands, the flags move apart, and the background image reveals hidden side parts.

Other examples of rubber websites are the sites of Mosmetrostroy and Mospromstroy.

Form and chaos

European web design is form. Russian web design is chaos.

European web design is the logical continuation of a century-long evolution of design. Russian web design is something that has broken out of the prison it was locked in a hundred years ago. It acts as if the 20th century never happened. It skipped the evolution toward form. It came from the past, from the world of pre-revolutionary advertising and eclecticism. In essence, Russian websites are built roughly as if they had been made in the 19th century.

European design is defined by strict rules, precision and harmony; it is solid, coherent, logical and well thought out. European websites don’t just exist: they convey an idea to the reader, give only the information that is needed and speak to the reader in their own language.

European websites look alike. After an hour of browsing website galleries, déjà vu sets in. All the sites are exceptionally good but exceptionally similar, like the neat rows of houses in an English village. Russian websites have only their general disorder in common, but each one is unique, like the carved log houses of a Russian village.

Looking at good Russian web design, you don’t feel strictness or a businesslike conversation. Instead, you feel freedom and open space. The site welcomes the reader with warmth and hospitality: it first talks about itself, asks how you are doing, pours you some tea and only then gradually gets down to business, now and then returning to small talk about the weather.

Adaptive, responsive and other bullshit

Today, European web design is taking timid steps toward a more sensible use of screen space. It is starting to realize that pages can stretch. Around 2011, the first primitive techniques for stretching web pages appear and are immediately hailed with great fanfare as “responsive” and “adaptive” layout. Now websites are made in two or three sizes for different screens, and product tiles in online stores stretch. Hopefully without jerks.

This great achievement of European design is immediately picked up by Russian designers and praised as something new, available only in HTML5. Some web studios even add a laughable separate item to their price lists: “adaptive website.”

Meanwhile, nobody remembers that back in 1999, fully rubber websites were being built with tables and worked in IE 5 and Netscape. Now Russian designers gaze adoringly at endless European websites that look like identical bricks, completely forgetting that for more than ten years they have had far more powerful and interesting layout techniques. It is an internet provincial’s inferiority complex. Adaptive design is nothing but marketing hype.

Someday Western web design will grow up to the level of Russian web design. It will happen at the moment Russian web design degrades to the level of Western.